Tuesday, December 30, 2008

Slumdog Millionaire

Slumdog Millionaire, as the name implies is a rags-to-riches story of a boy named Jamaal who goes from being a slumdog to becoming a millionaire through a TV show. The storyline may seem ingenuous, but the way the story is told is ingenious. We've seen many rags-to-riches stories, but this one is special in terms of its simplicity, credibility and the effect it has on the viewer. Adapted from a book, Q & A by Vikas Swarup, the movie is a joint venture by Danny Boyle and Loveleen Tandon.

Most of the movie weaves between the hero sitting on the "Who wants to be a millionaire" show and flashback scenes that show his journey to the seat. It is this interweaving that makes the story engrossing in the first half. The events portrayed in the childhood of Jamaal leave a lasting impression. The life in the slums and in Mumbai in general are shown very convincingly. The child actors(The three musketeers) have done a thoroughly commendable job.



The transition from childhood to adoloscence is brilliant, with a touch of Bollywood, in the scene where the hero and his brother are pushed off a train and after rolling on the ground for a few seconds, they get up as teenagers. The teenage Jamaal is played by the kid who played Ishaan's friend Rajan in Taare Zameen Par. He does a good job in the Taj Mahal scene where he becomes a guide, yarning bizarre stories about how the Taj Mahal was built. In this phase of the film, the focus is more on how the kids evolve and what they evolve into. You see Jamaal's brother Salim becoming a gangster and Jamaal himself becoming a chaiwala in a call-centre. The screenplay lags a bit in this part and you somehow feel the pace of the movie is lost. The movie tries to convey that young Jamaal would go to any extent to get what he wants(if he could do THAT for getting the autograph of Big B, he would do anything to get the love of his life). But due to the poor chemistry between the lead couple, it's hard to really sense that feeling of love. Just that Latika(played by Freida Pinto) is the most beautiful woman in the eyes of Jamaal is not reason enough to believe in the effect of love. With better actors perhaps, better chemistry could have been created. Dev Patel fails miserably in this regard.


The "Who wants to be a millionaire" scenes are really well-made, the set being that of Kaun Banega Crorepati, and Anil Kapoor playing Big B. He does a good job pretty much in the mould of Big B. The build-up to the show and its huge following are certainly justified as one can't forget that the show did create a similar wave in India. The music is simply out of the world, which is no wonder when it is by A.R.Rahman. The background pieces add great value to the scenes, be it Latika's theme or "Paper planes" by M.I.A or even the "Ringa Ringa" in the brothel scene. A definite contender for the OST award in the Oscars. Dialogue in the movie is more Indianized naturally, but as it is a Hollywood movie and as it has to reach a global audience, most of the dialogue is in English. It is pretty irritating to see local Indians(constables and young kids) speaking in English in Mumbai and leaves you wishing all the dialogue was in Hindi(which would have been more realistic and which would have meant the movie was directed by an Indian).

That is the thought I am left with after watching the movie. The resignation that Indian movie-makers haven't reached this level of sophistication yet. Never has a simple rags-to-riches story based in India been told so effectively by an Indian director. The spirit of Mumbai conveyed so beautifully by a Hollywood movie. Though there is the contribution of an Indian co-director, the major credits go to Danny Boyle. We can certainly expect this movie to bag a few Oscars and Golden Globes.

4 comments:

Unknown said...

Hey Sri,

I completely agree with u, the movie is swell!!

I don't agree though that Dev has failed to do his part in terms of acting. I think he has done a good job.

The movie has been very well received here. The turn out in a small theatre in Concord was very surprising and people stood up and applauded once the movie was over.

I recommend u watch Oye Lucky Oye and AAmir. I watched both the movies very recently and liked both. Guess you will like it too.

Sriganesh Murthi said...

Hey Alifya

Thanks for the read and comment. Ya it has received a great response globally. Wish I saw it in the theatres. Hasn't yet released here. Will watch it again when it does.

I have seen neither of those two movies u mentioned. Seen bits n pieces of Aamir though.

And come on, Dev was not all that good. The child Jamaal did a much better job at acting, I would say. :-) Anyway it's his first movie and I guess it was a decent enough performance for a debut.

Bharani said...

first of all...good movie...mediocre review...

second of all...it's not a rags-to-riches story...a rags-to-riches story would be something like "annamalai" where they show how one lives after getting rich and how one uses the money...in this, all of 10 minutes is what is shown after he gets his 20 million(2 crores (i am used to doing this!))... okay my point in the "Second of all" is, it's a story about luck and chances and more importantly, love...pursuit of the one and only thing he cares about...it's not about the money or the game-show, he did it only because he "..knew she'd be watching.."...

that leads me to the third of all...no chemistry?...i thought there was enough chemistry,the highest point of which is where they meet in in the mumbai railway station and when they drag her away in front of jamal...a.r.rahman's background score here is simply awesome...

fourth of all...yes, there were some cinematic elements, like the teenage jamal making money at taj (come on, foreigners are not that dumb)...and yes, indian directors need to learn a thing or two from boyle...credits to tandon who has made it as india-friendly as possible...

finally, great acting by the young actors,some impeccable performances...

p.s. i don't know why i am in a "sriganesh-bashing-mood" today...

Sriganesh Murthi said...

@Bharani:

well, yeah... i myself wasn't really satisfied with my review... i liked the movie, but not cos of all the elements that you mentioned - luck, love, chances, destiny.... i believe in none of that crap - that's why.... :-)